I have a confession. I know this is horrible, but I recently watched a you tube video titled "ugliest girl in the world" for the shear curiosity of watching what I thought was going to be an amazingly homely, overweight, 40 year old woman croak out a pop song. And I snickered quietly because - Ha Ha - at least I'm not *that* ugly! But my revelry at my own good genetic fortune turned to ashes with the sudden and horrifying realization that the creature I was watching was actually an adolescent girl. In an instant I remembered how much it stung the day my grade school crush called me ugly. I think I cried for days. I can't even imagine what it would have felt like to have fourteen thousand people agree with him on a public message board. That poor girl is going to have a very very difficult journey through this life with the face of an unhealthy 40 year old woman.
I've been thinking a lot this week about beauty. It's come up in articles and documentaries, it's in my circles, conversations, and well - I'm having trouble squeezing into my size 12 pants (formerly known as my "fat pants") which means it's time to break out the old eating disorder, dust it off, and put it to work. So beauty is on my mind.
Do we already have it?
There's a Dove commercial circulating that reminds us women that other people probably see us as more beautiful than we see ourselves. All of us women have a tendency to judge ourselves more harshly than we judge others. Serioulsy, the only women I personally know who are actually ugly - are made so more by their personality than their physical appearance. So why do we all have such low self esteem? Did all of you have some 25 year old kid draw a charicature of you with no hair and covered in zits and nick name you dragon lady? Cause that's my excuse. Maybe that type of incident is more common than I realize. Thanks for the pep talk, Dove - but it's too hard for us to reconcile the message of how pretty we all are with the message of how pretty we are not.
Should we care about it?
A blogized rebuttal to this Dove commercial is also making the rounds. It's a righteous and angry conviction from the feminist rebel that dwells deep within all of us. We are more than physical beauty! take up your hippy dresses and doc martin boots, shave your heads, and lets march on our enemies and tear down the corporate machinations that keep us subservient to moisturizers and push up bras! Ok... well I'm paraphrasing a little. But the point is - being obsessed with beauty is shallow. It's so true. But are we really happier to ignore beauty altogether?
Can we really fight BioSocioPsychoEconomics?
Ya. I made that word up. But my point is, there is some scientific basis to our reaction to beauty. Evolutionarily - beauty ensures genetic traits get propagated. From our earliest ancestor, who chose to mate with the opposable thumbed pre-ape - to today, where we subconsciously (or consciously, if we're shallow) make snap judgements about a stranger's socioeconomic background, value system, and general health based on what they look like. We can vow to not let physical appearance affect the way we treat others - in fact, I strongly advocate for that position - but you can't change your wiring. And it won't change the fact that others are still going to judge you by your looks, and then treat you accordingly.
What if there are two kinds of beauty?
I was watching a documentary (about Mr. Rogers. It was good) and someone was talking about finding beauty in the world. It was their belief that, if people could just take the time to find the beauty in a sunset, or enjoy the simple beauty of a gorgeous day that it would effect the way we all see and treat each other. That might be a little too granola for me, but I think there's a crumb of truth in there. I recently found a site for artists that had hundreds of references of the human form. Mostly naked. Young, old, men, women, fat, skinny, and in all of them the photographer had managed to capture a simple beauty. Their diversity was magnificent, their emotion, their expectant hope and lives before them. Yes, even you tube girl would be beautiful as a study in human diversity, and form, and light and shadow. Are there two kinds of beauty? A shallow, superficial one, and deep, natural one? Is the Dove corporation looking at one kind, and 25 year old boys another?
Where does all this leave me?
There is a little you tube girl in all of us. If we look at her through the eyes of an artist, or a free spirit, or a Dove advertising genius - we are deep, gracious, and fulfilled. But we are also going to be judged as having less social worth by a cruel and biologically/psycho-socially programmed society designed to make life easier for pretty people. But if we take that inner child and starve her, paint her up to cover her flaws, and straighten her hair - people will be nicer to us, smile at us more, hold the door and find reasons to make conversation in the elevator. But we'll be shallow, and the ideal we seek is ultimately unattainable, so we'll also be unsatisfied. Maybe I can find some kind of happy medium, where I fit in these pants.
Chatboard (0)